Unraveling the Anchors: How Your Brain Makes Sense of the World (And Gets It Wrong)


Hi All!

Here is my weekly letter on mental models, performance, business and entrepreneurship.

If you love this content (please share it), but also…

Check out my Podcast, connect with me on YouTube / Twitter, and read my daily newsletter.

What’s in today’s newsletter?

  1. The Power of Anchoring: The anchoring effect is a psychological bias where the first piece of information we receive strongly influences our subsequent judgments, even if that initial information is unrelated to the decision at hand.

  2. Anchoring is Everywhere: This bias isn't confined to shopping; it surfaces in negotiations, investing, and even how we form first impressions. Understanding anchoring helps us resist its unconscious pull.

  3. Use Anchors Wisely: We can harness anchoring to our advantage. In negotiations, setting a strong opening offer becomes an anchor. Counter-anchors can also be deployed to reshape the negotiation landscape.

Sponsor: Netsuite

I’ve seen a lot of business tools come and go, but nothing has transformed my operations quite like NetSuite by Oracle. When you’re running a business pulling in millions in revenue, you don’t have time for inefficiencies.This is where NetSuite shines: it grants unparalleled visibility, empowers rapid decision-making, and streamlines every department.

And guess what? For the first time in their 22-year reign as the top cloud financial system, they’re offering a chance to defer your FULL NetSuite implementation payments for six whole months. That’s ZERO payments, ZERO interest. I’ve felt the power of having all my business insights consolidated, and now, with an offer this unprecedented, it’s your turn.

Dive in, and join the ranks of the 33,000 businesses already harnessing NetSuite’s prowess.

Sign Up Now

Anchors Aweigh: What Is This Thing, Anyway?

Today, we're diving deep into the world of anchoring, a cognitive bias that influences our choices far more pervasively than we realize. 

If you’ve heard of Anchors before, you’ve probably heard it in a sales context. I’ll touch on that, but it goes way deeper than this.

Understanding Anchoring isn't just about dodging sneaky sales tactics; it's about understanding how our brains construct reality from imperfect information.

Anchors Aweigh: What Is This Thing, Anyway?

Picture this: You're browsing for a new jacket. The first one you see is beautiful, but it's a whopping $400. Way out of your budget. However, as you wander through the store, every other jacket now seems like a relative bargain. Suddenly, that $150 option looks downright appealing.

That initial $400 price tag served as an anchor. It distorted your perception of what constitutes a "reasonable" price for a jacket. This mental glitch, my friends, is the anchoring effect in action.

Another (non sales, example), was shown that if people are first asked whether Gandhi died before or after age 9, and are then asked to guess Gandhi's actual age at death, their guesses will be lower than if they had first been asked whether Gandhi lived past age 200. The first anchor of 9 or 200 pulls their final estimate in that direction, despite it having no logical relevance.

The anchoring bias describes our mind's tendency to become overly influenced by the first piece of information (the anchor) it receives on a topic. Once that anchor's dropped, subsequent judgments get made relative to it, even if the initial anchor is totally arbitrary or irrelevant.

Anchoring in the Wild

Anchoring isn't just about shopping sprees and impulse buys. It permeates all sorts of life decisions:

  • Negotiations: The person who throws out a number first (salary, sale price, you name it) often has an advantage because it sets the psychological stage for the rest of the negotiation.

  • Investing: Get too fixated on the price you originally paid for a stock? You might miss signs it's time to sell, even if the fundamentals have changed (that's sunk cost fallacy, a close cousin of anchoring).

  • First Impressions: From job interviews to dating, that initial impression (positive or negative) can color how people perceive everything else you do.

Anchors: The Cognitive Comfort Blanket

Think of an anchor as a mental shortcut. Our brains crave stability and order – they don't enjoy floating around in a sea of uncertainty. Anchors, even irrelevant ones, give us a point of reference, a starting line from which to judge everything else.

The tricky part? Once an anchor is planted in our minds, it has a cascading effect:

  • Selective Attention: We start noticing details that confirm the established anchor and downplay information that contradicts it. This is a form of confirmation bias.

  • Distorted Valuation: An anchor can make something seem outrageously expensive or like an incredible deal, even if the objective value remains unchanged. Our point of reference becomes skewed.

  • The Ripple Effect: Anchors don't just affect isolated decisions. They can have a long-term influence on our spending habits, expectations, and even our beliefs about the world.

Why Are Our Brains So Easily Swayed?

Researchers have a few theories:

  • Effort Reduction: Our brains are cognitive misers—they love shortcuts. Instead of thoroughly evaluating every decision from scratch, referencing an anchor is a quick, albeit imperfect, decision-making hack.

  • Uncertainty: When clueless about a fair price or course of action, any initial data point seems better than none. The anchor gives us some place to start.

The World is Your Anchor Playground

Let's be real, anchors are everywhere:

  • The "Free Trial" Trap: That initial "Free" frames future pricing decisions. Suddenly the monthly subscription feels way less appealing, even if the total cost is reasonable. Companies know this.

  • The Power of Suggestion: Have you noticed how tip options on those card readers keep getting higher? They're anchoring your perception of what constitutes a "normal" tip amount.

  • Anchoring in the Social Realm: The first opinion you hear on a controversial topic, or even just the initial word choice ("riot" vs. "protest"), can shape how you process subsequent information.

The Achilles Heel of Anchoring

The most insidious thing about anchors is that they work even when we KNOW they exist. Studies show that even when people are explicitly warned about anchoring bias, it still influences their estimation and judgment.

Why does this happen? Here's where things get interesting:

  • Anchors Tap Into Deeper Thinking: System 1 thinking (fast, intuitive) is easily swayed by anchors. But while System 2 (slow, deliberate reasoning) can recognize the bias, it takes significant effort to fully counteract its effects.

  • Relative, Not Absolute: Our brains are wired to assess things comparatively. Even if you intellectually recognize that an anchor is arbitrary, your emotional response is primed to the comparison.

  • The Fluency Factor: Anchors create a sense of cognitive fluency. Options that feel familiar or easy to process often seem intuitively correct, even if they aren't the most rational choice.

Fight Back Against the Invisible Hand

So, are we doomed to be cognitive puppets manipulated by random anchors? Not quite. Here's your toolkit:

  • The Art of Delayed Gratification: Impulse buys are the best friend of anchoring. Give yourself time. Before reacting to a price, offer, or information, impose a self-mandated waiting period. That pause gives your logical brain space to catch up.

  • Seek Counter-Anchors: Never rely on a single data point. Actively seek out alternative pricing, multiple opinions, or different perspectives on an issue. This helps break the spell of the initial anchor.

  • Embrace Strategic Ambiguity: Especially in negotiations, sometimes it pays to be the one who avoids stating the first number. Strategic ambiguity shifts the dynamic in your favor.

Beyond the Obvious – Anchoring in Unexpected Places

Anchoring isn't just a salesperson's trick. It seeps into areas where we least expect it, subtly shaping our choices, opinions, and even our self-perception:

  • Anchoring to the Past: Ever catch yourself longing for "the good old days" when things seemed cheaper, simpler, or better? Those nostalgic memories can become anchors, making us resistant to change or less receptive to the advantages of the present.

  • The Self-Perception Anchor: Our initial impressions of ourselves (in childhood through early adulthood) have incredible staying power. That old "I'm bad at math" label can linger for decades, leading to missed opportunities because we're anchored to a past limitation.

  • Anchoring in the Courtroom: Studies suggest that even something as trivial as the severity of a sentencing demand by the prosecution can unconsciously anchor the judge's ultimate sentence, regardless of the actual evidence.

Anchors: A Double-Edged Sword

It's important to remember, anchoring isn't inherently good or bad. Our brains evolved this shortcut for a reason. Here's where it can be helpful:

  • Goal Setting as Anchoring: Ever heard the advice to "visualize success"? It's partly an anchoring effect. Setting a high initial goal (sales revenue, fitness target, creative output) creates a reference point that can motivate us, even if we don't fully reach the first ambitious mark.

  • Positive Self-Talk: Consciously reframing negative thought patterns with positive affirmations can be a form of beneficial self-anchoring. Over time, it helps shift your internal reference point.

  • Anchors for Social Good: Charities that display suggested donation amounts or non-profits highlighting the impact of even small contributions are leveraging anchoring principles to nudge people towards greater generosity.

The Ultimate Goal: Cognitive Flexibility

It's not about eliminating anchors – they're an inevitable part of how our brains work. The key is becoming mindful of when they're operating, knowing when to deliberately set our own anchors, and developing the flexibility to shift our reference points when necessary.

Understanding anchoring is a step towards greater objectivity, better decision-making, and a healthy skepticism towards the hidden forces trying to shape our reality.

Let's get meta - could this newsletter be one big anchor to get you thinking more critically about decision-making? Absolutely 😉


Other Partners (They Have Some Special Offers For Readers.. Check Them Out)

Scott's Newsletter logo
Subscribe to Scott's Newsletter and never miss a post.