Understanding the Basics of Profit and Loss Calculation for Crypto Assets

This issue is brought to you by Tokenpad:

Tokenpad generates and earnings report for each asset you hold, across your crypto wallets.

The app is now live on the App store and Google Play store.

The Profit and Loss (PnL) represents the financial performance of an investment. It’s how much money was gained or lost compared to the initial investment made into the asset. 

In the context of cryptocurrency, PnL indicates the difference between the amount invested in crypto assets and their current or sold value. A positive PnL means a profit, while a negative PnL indicates a loss.

You can’t learn to invest better if you don’t know if you’re making money. Understanding PnL is crucial for crypto investors to evaluate their investment strategies and make informed decisions.

Due to the volatile nature of cryptocurrencies, accurately calculating PnL helps investors track their performance, manage risks, and optimize their portfolios to achieve better returns.

In this series of Articles, we will dive deep into crypto profit and loss calculation, today, we start with the basics.

• Realized PnL: This is the profit or loss generated from completed transactions. For example, if you bought 1 Bitcoin at $10,000 and sold it all at $15,000, the $5,000 gain is your realized profit.

• Unrealized PnL: Also known as "paper gains or losses," this refers to the profit or loss on investments that you still hold. If you bought 1 Bitcoin at $10,000 and its current value is $15,000 but you haven't sold it yet, the $5,000 is an unrealized gain.

• Total PnL: The sum of the realized and unrealized PnL

• Total cost basis: This is the total money you’ve put into an asset originally. It’s the purchase price of each unit times the amount of units you bought. It is essential for calculating capital gains and losses, and thus for determining PnL. You compare it with the current value of the asset, or the value of the asset when you sold it to determine the profit or loss.

• Average cost basis: The average cost basis refers to the case when you’ve bought an asset multiple times over time at different prices, this is the weighted average of the price you’re getting.

• Lot: This refers to a specific batch of assets, such as shares or crypto tokens, that are bought together at the same time and price. Each lot has its own purchase date, quantity, and cost basis (the purchase price). Tracking lots is crucial for accurately calculating profit and loss (PnL) and optimizing tax strategies, as different accounting methods (like FIFO, LIFO, or HIFO) can be applied to determine which lots are sold or depleted first, impacting the realized gains or losses.

It’s likely that you’re not tracking your realized profits, and we believe that you can’t learn to invest better if you don’t know if you’re making money.

A crucial aspect of understanding your investments is distinguishing between realized and unrealized PnL. Unrealized PnL is what most investors are familiar with. It represents the current gain or loss on your holdings based on the market price. For example, if you bought Bitcoin at $10,000 and it's now worth $20,000, your unrealized PnL is $10,000.

However, realized PnL is equally (or more) important but often overlooked. Realized PnL is the profit or loss that you actually lock in when you sell or trade your crypto assets. For instance, if you sell 1 Bitcoin that you bought for $50,000 at the current price of $20,000, your realized PnL is -$30,000. Realized PnL affects your tax obligations directly and can provide a clearer picture of your investment performance.

Investors tend to focus on unrealized PnL because it is visible in real-time on their portfolios. Yet, realizing gains or losses by executing trades is a critical part of effective portfolio management. Understanding both realized and unrealized PnL allows you to make informed decisions about when to buy, hold, or sell your assets to maximize returns and manage risks efficiently.

We will dive deeper into this topic in our next couple of articles. Make sure to subscribe to stay tuned. 

If you have incomplete or incorrect records, it can lead to no PnL calculation, or a miscalculated PnL, impacting financial decisions:

• You may think that you’re making good investments, but when analyzing the accurate data, you realize that your investments had not been good at all

• Your tax calculations may be incorrect, leading you to pay for more taxes than you should

If you only deal with a couple of transactions or assets, it’s relatively easy to maintain accurate records, but there’s a point where it might become a headache to calculate your PnL.

Accurate transaction history is vital for PnL calculation. Each buy, sell, and transfer affects the cost basis and the resulting PnL. Keeping detailed records ensures precise tracking of performance over time.

Manual tracking involves recording each transaction in a spreadsheet or ledger. While more labor-intensive, it offers complete control over your records and can be a good option for those with fewer transactions, but once you have more than a couple hundred transactions, calculating profit and loss manually is a headache.

Using apps like Tokenpad simplifies the process of tracking transactions. These apps automatically sync with your crypto wallets, providing real-time updates on your holdings, prices, transactions, and overall PnL. This is how is looks in Tokenpad:

Example 1: You buy 1 Bitcoin at $10,000 and later sell it all at $15,000.

• Cost Basis: $10,000

• Selling Price: $15,000

• Realized Profit: $15,000 - $10,000 = $5,000

• Unrealized Profit: $0, because you sold everything

Example 2: You buy 2 ETH at $500 each (total $1,000) and then sell 1 ETH at $1,000.

• Average Cost Basis for each unit of ETH: $500

• Total Cost Basis: $1000

• Selling Price for the 1 ETH sold: $1,000

• Realized Profit: $1,000 - $500 = +$500 on the first ETH

• Unrealized PnL for remaining ETH: If the current price is $1,200, unrealized PnL is $1,200 - $500 = $700

• Total PnL: $500 + $700 = $1,200

It’s important to note on the second example that the total PnL is made up of both the unrealized, and realized PnL. It’s crucial to analyze both of these as a whole, to understand in a full picture the status of the portfolio.

Understanding PnL is crucial for managing and optimizing crypto investments. Realized and unrealized PnL, cost basis, and accurate transaction history are foundational concepts for calculating investment performance. Both automated and manual tracking methods work, but accurate record-keeping is essential in either case.

You can use automated tools like Tokenpad to streamline this process and start making better informed decisions.

In the next articles, we will delve deeper into advanced PnL calculation methods and formulas with complex examples. We will explore the impact of different lot accounting techniques (FIFO, LIFO, HIFO), and discuss strategies to maximize tax efficiency in cryptocurrency investments.

Stay tuned for a comprehensive guide to mastering PnL calculations in the dynamic world of crypto.

Disclosure: All content published is for informational purposes only, and does not constitute any sort of financial advice.