Welcome to the 81 new members who have joined us since the last week!
If you havenāt subscribed, join ~10,000 digital artists and collectors by subscribing here or upgrade to the premium plan:
The NFT art space has suffered tremendously from X (formerly Twitter š) link-blocking updates.
The updates - designed to keep people on X - were implemented almost in sync with the so-called NFT bear market.
The fact that most blockchain artists, marketplaces, and products rely almost entirely on X for marketing (mint links, announcements, discovery) has made things much worse, as creators are left frustrated, wondering if their work is terrible or if anyone cares.
You arenāt alone; this has affected everyone, from small creators to massive marketplaces.
Here is a look at my traffic originating from X since I started my newsletter.

Ouch, that doesn't look promisingā¦
The good news is Iāve maintained the newsletter growth despite this drastic drop, the dry market conditions, and seemingly less interest in the space.

My newsletter issues are read by 100% more people than one year ago. This data keeps me motivated as it shows artists and collectors are still here, but we must find better ways to connect.
4 Unconventional Ways to Grow and Own Your Audience
These are unconventional ways Iāve used to grow my audience and find people that genuily care about what I am doing ā despite market conditions and the mysterious algorithms that govern us.
https://zora.co/collect/zora:0xb6bdc5a8f83b40cb162d68f2e7258a0e37c74407/31. Start a Newsletter
I couldnāt recommend this enough. Owning your audience email list is the best way to overcome dependency and ensure your creations reach those who care.
A newsletter wonāt boost your growth, but you will own your audience, something nobody canāt take away (except your subscribers, as they can unsubscribe anytime). Think of your newsletter as your audience companion and an efficient way to share timely updates or releases.
How to do it:
Sign up for a free newsletter platform. I recommend Substack or Paragraph. Paragraph is an excellent alternative for blockchain creators as it lets your audience subscribe by email or crypto wallets. You could embed NFTs into your emails, airdrop your newsletter to wallets, and manage your collectors onchain.
Include your newsletter sign-up form in your social accounts, linktree, website, and email footer.
Write a short weekly or bi-weekly summary of what you are working on. An overview of your social posts works āthink 2 to 4 min reads, not whitepapers.
Besides updates, you can send direct links to your newest art or creations. Mind your audience and your drop cadence (!); nobody wants to get sales spam every day.
2. Join a Decentralized Social Network
There are plenty of decentralized social networks or alternatives to X. Iāve explored almost all! Mastodon, Threads, Lens, Farcasterā¦ So far, Iāve been enjoying Farcaster the most.
Decentralized social networks merit an entire article, but in short, they let you own your assets via the blockchain and avoid being hurt by the network making arbitrary decisions.
Farcaster has a yearly protocol fee of $7 to $12, which keeps spammers and bots away. Quality content and conversations from blockchain and crypto enthusiasts occur every day. This network grows quickly, onboarding over 1,000 weekly users, including popular names like Vitalik Buterin and Brian Armstrong.
Interesting benefits:
Your profile, content, followers, and NFTs are tied to your wallet and can be ported to different Farcaster apps.
NFT collections are automatically shown, and actions such as the latest mints and protocol rewards are integrated (or will be) into all the interactions.
I now have over 2,000 new followers (high quality) that I wouldnāt have found elsewhere.
How to do it:
Open a Farcaster account, download the Warpcaster mobile app, and pay the protocol.
Fill out your profile, and include a link to your site or newsletter.
There are specific groups for art, gen artists, musicians, podcasters, writers, etc. Find your tribe and start engaging with other creators and sharing your work. Remember to share high-quality and thoughtful content.
3. Start a YouTube Channel
Overlooked in our space, YouTubeās potential is undeniable, as it is the second most used search engine after Google. Iāve been uploading podcast episodes on my channel since a month ago, and although the beginning can be slow, most of the traffic is from a new audience that isnāt familiar with my content. It has been a great way to reach new readers and listeners.
You can create long-form videos, medium-form (1 minute to 15 minutes), and shorts (below 1 minute).
Shorts hold particular value for artists and creators for their practicality and reach potential. This has worked for many creators over Instagram reels and works on YouTube, too.
How to do it:
Create a YouTube channel, and fill in all your details (website, social networks, your site, and collections).
Share your videos; you can start with shorts and see what works. Include links to your creation, newsletter, website, and social accounts in the video descriptions.
YouTubeās algorithm tries to find people interested in your content, so use related keywords in the title or description. Compared to other social networks, YouTube constantly shares old videos, so once on your channel, it will continue to get views over time.
From there, it is about finding ways to optimize your videos; this isnāt easy and requires a lot of research, but if you enjoy this form, it can surpass your other channels.
Tip: Repurpose your videos for social networks like Instagram, Twitter, etc.
4. Get on Reddit
Reddit is one of the most used platforms on the web. They have incorporated NFT features via their avatars, which hints they take NFTs seriously. It is built on subreddits (or subcommunities), and the trick is to find the right communities that align with your creations.
Iāve also seen visual artists and creators go viral on Reddit.

The most important thing on Reddit is to authentically interact with others and not be too pushy. Reddit isnāt a marketplace or a billboard app.
How to do it:
Create your account and fill your profile with a link to your newsletter, social platforms, YouTube, website, and creations.
Join subreddits related to your work. Here are some of my favorites for digital artists:
Share your creations, stories, and tools in the right subreddit āno links, no promotion! Seek authentic conversations, be curious, and engage with interesting creators.
While doing it, your ākarmaā points will increase (your reputation), and people will get curious. Eventually, your socials, websites, and newsletter will get new traffic that converts to your inner audience and supporters.
Conclusion
Given how aggressively X has cut link sharing over the past year, it is mandatory for artists, projects, and companies that rely solely on this social network to find alternatives.
Each platform is different and has its pros and cons. It takes time to learn them well, but exploring options with an open mind is worth it, especially during these uncertain times. I wouldnāt recommend trying multiple platforms at once; instead, start a newsletter (Paragraph for blockchain integrations or Substack) and choose an additional platform like Farcaster, YouTube, or Reddit.
Slowly include it in your routine, enjoy the process, and grow and take ownership of your audience.
Until next time,
- Kaloh
https://zora.co/collect/zora:0xb6bdc5a8f83b40cb162d68f2e7258a0e37c74407/3This essay was originally posted at https://www.kaloh.xyz
Thanks for the tips, learned something new āļø
Great to hear that!
Back in November 2023, I wrote 'Unconventional ways to grow and own your audience' This was before @farcaster became popoular. Time proved this was great advice... Read & subscribe below š https://paragraph.xyz/@kaloh/unconventional-ways-to-grow-and-own-your-audience
aged well š
š¤regarding paragraph and hypersubā¦ can you collect all your hyper subs subscribers into a paragraph list? What happens if there are ZK rollups, and the whole social scene explodes again?
If they share their email, you can add them to paragraph I donāt understand the question about ZK roll ups
Farcaster requires users to build a new list of followers. What would you do if rollups evolve on chains other than BASE or Optimism (Bitcoin?) that you want to use? Hypersub list may only contain base wallets? Idk š¤
That is why building an email list is important - that way you arenāt platform dependent (Iām not familiar with ZK roll ups, so I donāt understand that point well rn) I wrote about that here š https://paragraph.xyz/@kaloh/unconventional-ways-to-grow-and-own-your-audience
hypersub nfts can be deployed on eth mainnet, op, base, and zora. creators can export a list of addresses for whatever network their subscription nft is deployed on. if the user enters their email address after subscribing, that can be exported as well
Even @xcopy.eth (prob #1 audience in crypto art) is impressed by @farcaster just a few days in Back in November, I wrote about the importance of building an audience for creators and how @farcaster is key to owning instead of renting https://paragraph.xyz/@kaloh/unconventional-ways-to-grow-and-own-your-audience
Kalo this is great info. Thank you. Will read it more properly later but it gives me ideas
Glad it helps š
Testing the new @paragraph frame with an article I wrote a few months ago How to grow and own your audience? https://paragraph.xyz/@kaloh/unconventional-ways-to-grow-and-own-your-audience
.@bountycaster 100 USDC to diagnose & fix issues with certain URLs not appearing on Searchcaster 2 examples of URLs shared on FC but missing from Searchcaster: paragraph.xyz/@kaloh/unconventional-ways-to-grow-and-own-your-audience dwr.email/go-to-directly-to-jail
Searchcaster repo: https://github.com/gskril/searchcaster FC indexer repo: https://github.com/gskril/farcaster-indexer @greg may also be able to point you in the right direction
@bountybot whoops tagged the wrong bot
I'm actually pretty interested in this too since it may affect Bountycaster. @bountybot chip in 10 USDC please š«”
@greg is there any opportunity to perform our own queries on Searchcaster's Supabase? are you able to see the casts mentioned by Colin are indexed correctly? or do you think it's an information retrieval / query problem?
idk if there's an easy/secure way to open it up, but you should be able to get it running locally by following the readme here https://github.com/gskril/farcaster-indexer/ it won't index as far back as in the prod database but should be more than enough for testing
Is there a chance you could simply peek in the dataset and see if those casts that were mentioned in this thread are indexed? I know itās an ask, so no worries if you canāt right now. Knowing the answer to this saves us a lot of time. ļæ¼
@kenny any ideas?
The issue is that searchcasterās URL search expects http/https:// in the cast text, but the links you shared donāt have it. If you do a normal text search for those links without the protocol included they show up correctly
I donāt think theyāre always showing up, eg https://warpcast.com/kaloh/0xe7b755a1
Ah I see I have noticed other non-url missing casts recently too, so I wonder if thereās a larger issue with SC
with my quick check, "@" within URLs makes trouble on searchcaster. If you include "@" in a query, you cannot get expected search results. For "go-to-direct-to-jail", some of casts includes "." after the URL as a part of URL string, which makes a trouble as follows (this is not a problem on warpcast web client) :
gm āļø Just shared 'Unconventional ways to grown and own your audience' This is how I managed to grow my newsletter and audience, despite X link blocking features and the bear market. mentioned: @paragraph @farcaster https://paragraph.xyz/@kaloh/unconventional-ways-to-grow-and-own-your-audience
@greg looks like Searchcaster isn't showing this post either, so the comments aren't showing up: https://searchcaster.xyz/search?text=paragraph.xyz%2F%40kaloh%2Funconventional-ways-to-grow-and-own-your-audience Any idea why? Same issue that happened with Dan's post earlier?
Actually, it looks like Searchcaster is delayed - latest entry was from 5 days ago:
thx really interesting. Do you think this type of process is also beneficial for "contemporary trad" artists? For audience that's not just crypto-native, what's the interest of paragraph compared to writing on medium? same for reddit ?am curious bc art audience art mostly on instagram
The newsletter is important for any kind of creator. If the audience isn't crypto native, Substack or Beehiiv could be better options. The important thing is to own the email list and avoid being dependant on platforms - algorithms like Instagram, Twitter, etc. Medium doesn't solve that problem entirely
@pierrepauze if your audience is on Instagram for trad artists, that is ok, the focus can be on Instagram but guiding that audience to the newsletter
I think you're right, but personally I receive so much mail that I don't read the newsletters, even from my fellow artists, I feel it's like spam.