thoughts onchain
Cover photo

Private Companies Can Provide Public Goods

Merkle Manufactory created the Farcaster Protocol as a Public Good

Chris Carella

Chris Carella

A public good is a good or service that is both non-excludable and non-rivalrous.

Pure Public Goods are valuable things (goods, information, services, etc) that cannot charge money. For example, clean air is a public good because if you pay for a factory to install pollution reducing mechanisms I get cleaner air for free. The factory cannot reduce the pollution you breathe without also reducing the pollution I breathe. [Optimism]

As Vitalik Buterin notes, when economists' definition of Public Goods interacts with the real world "in almost any specific case there are all kinds of subtle edge cases that need to be treated differently. A park is a public good. But what if you add a $5 entrance fee? What if you fund it by auctioning off the right to have a statue of the winner in the park's central square?" [Vitalik]

The definition of a Pure Public Goods is therefore insufficient to make funding decisions. "Most things are not pure public goods: they are some hybrid in the middle, and there are many dimensions on which they could become more or less public that do not easily map to "exclusion"" [Vitalik]


However, Private Companies can offer both Pure and hybrid Public Goods. The term Public Good is typically utilized to characterize resources. [Chaomons] Some examples:

Satellite imagery

Private companies such as Google and Maxar Technologies provide satellite imagery that is used for a variety of public purposes, such as mapping, disaster relief, and environmental monitoring.

Open-source software

Private companies such as Google and Facebook provide open-source software that is used by millions of people around the world, including government agencies and educational institutions. Google created TensorFlow. Facebook created llama. Merkle Manufactory created Farcaster.

Medical research

Private companies such as Pfizer and Moderna invest billions of dollars in medical research, which leads to new drugs and treatments that benefit everyone in society.

Renewable energy

Private companies such as Tesla are developing and deploying renewable energy technologies that help to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and combat climate change.

Philanthropy

Private companies and their foundations often donate money to support public goods such as education, healthcare, and environmental protection.



Future Topics:

  • Public Goods Funding

  • What constitutes a Public Good for Protocols such as Farcaster and Optimism?

  • Pure Public Goods vs Impure Public Goods

  • Public Goods vs Common Goods

Collect this post as an NFT.

thoughts onchain

Subscribe to thoughts onchain to receive new posts directly to your inbox.

Over 600 subscribers

revFarcaster
rev
Commented 10 months ago

how do you define public goods?

revFarcaster
rev
Commented 10 months ago
revFarcaster
rev
Commented 10 months ago

@ccarella.eth comment ft. public goods tinkering w/ @jacob https://warpcast.com/ccarella.eth/0xcb6cba78

revFarcaster
rev
Commented 10 months ago
revFarcaster
rev
Commented 10 months ago

@ccarella.eth on private companies creating public goods https://warpcast.com/ccarella.eth/0x33a22bee

Chris CarellaFarcaster
Chris Carella
Commented 10 months ago
revFarcaster
rev
Commented 10 months ago

thanks for sharing! 1000 $REGEN

Luciano Farcaster
Luciano
Commented 10 months ago

something that everyone can use but doesn’t have a clear business model to sustain itself

revFarcaster
rev
Commented 10 months ago

Interesting take! what do you think about the intersection of profitability and public goods? say, social businesses? 420 $REGEN

Luciano Farcaster
Luciano
Commented 10 months ago

i think if a public good is profitable, for example a botanical garden, then it should use it’s profits to expand and better maintain its grounds

Octant  ⧫Farcaster
Octant ⧫
Commented 10 months ago

One challenge we've found is the definition, because of the name "public goods", doesn't consider scale. If its a public good for 2 people, is it still a public good? How much of the public must it benefit? Non rivalrous, non excludable goods that benefit the commons in the community. Although this is still grey..

revFarcaster
rev
Commented 10 months ago

love this take. agree that the definition in a way could be dynamic, considering the context in each specific case. 1000 $REGEN

SophiaFarcaster
Sophia
Commented 10 months ago

value created - value captured

revFarcaster
rev
Commented 10 months ago

420 $REGEN

humptyFarcaster
humpty
Commented 1 year ago

Seeing as how Gitcoin is a leader in the public goods space and future @ccarella.eth articles are related to public goods and PGF I think it makes sense to continue this discussion here Would be good to see @owocki + other Gitcoin fam share their thoughts too https://paragraph.xyz/@ccarella/pg-private-companies

humptyFarcaster
humpty
Commented 1 year ago
KiwiFarcaster
Kiwi
Commented 1 year ago

Private companies can provide public goods 4 upvotes, submitted to @kiwi by @timdaub.eth

timdaubFarcaster
timdaub
Commented 1 year ago

this is the kiwi circle of life. @ccarella.eth posts smth, the @kiwi community picks it up, and if it's great, we endorse it as a collective

Private Companies Can Provide Public Goods