mxjxn musings
Cover photo

A Curated Cryptoart Channel

An ongoing experiment in crowdsourcing curation.

Max Jackson

Max Jackson

Censorship and gatekeeping has been an ongoing battle for artists in the world of cryptoart. On Warpcast, it is no longer to censor a cast from the main timeline but a channel's main feed remained curated, either by a moderator or by the default algorithm. Neither are the right answer for an art community, so we are changing that.

Today we are taking steps to create an artist-curated main feed for the /cryptoart channel.

Our initial approach

The current strategy is two-pronged. If you wish to be seen on the main timeline, you must either mint an OE from the /cryptoart channel DAO, or be curated. On day one, our list of curators is quite long in hopes of getting a significant amount of curation on the feed.

Any curator may curate a cast from the recent feed to the main feed. Only DAO Council may downvote. It takes two downvotes to remove a cast from the main feed. In order to ensure a decent quantity of curation happens, we will continue to add curators from our community ranks.

post image
The list of curators at the time of publication

If you hold any token from the /cryptoart DAO OE contract, you will be seen on the main feed. The open editions will continue to be free+fee on Base via Zora and will always be available. The current live mint at time of publication is Southside Falls by @wgmeets.

https://zora.co/collect/base:0xce4f649d4ef8fee2e6628184892a54d226308b89/2

The curation strategy is in flux

As we work with the community to determine the best way of curating the feed, our moderation strategy will change. Several people have noted that token-gating is not curating but filtering and financially gatekeeping. While the OE is very inexpensive, I recognize that it may limit access for several quality contributors to the channel who dont currently hold enough ETH or cant afford to bridge to Base.

To correct this issue, we are considering removing the token-gated feature in lieu of token-gating a curator role. That means anyone who has minted a token becomes a curator. There are currently 850 unique addresses holding a token from the CRYPTOART contract. That could very well be too many people to give a curator role to.

We will revise the rules on a regular basis. When a strategy proves to not be effective or the community has expressed a lot of discontent with it, we will make adjustments. As the DAO continues to develop new projects, the curation strategy may change along the way.

We need your feedback

You as a community member are a part of this. If you are discontent with the state of the /cryptoart channel or its curation, please speak up on the timeline (or directly in DMs) and talk about why. If you have any ideas, share them. I certainly cant determine the best moderation strategy by myself. Neither I nor the DAO council can represent the community if you dont let us know how you feel about the channel.

Some background on the channel

The Farcaster /cryptoart channel has been live since the day permissionless channels launched in October 2023. It has grown from under 10 casts a day to over 500 a day. When /cryptoart DAO launched, we began our work towards making the channel a curatorial entity driven by the community. We then created an open edition collection as an easy way to gain membership and participate. After the first mint, we held a curation contest requiring holding one or more editions to participate.

The future of /cryptoart curation

The main feed is not the only thing we are curating. Aside from Open Editions, we intend to work more closely with artists in our community. We want to provide artists with opportunities to reach a greater audience and find new collectors. We are discussing ideas on the public timeline, in the private DAO Council chat, in the CRYPTOART chat for OE holders, and in the public Cryptoart Cabal chat.

Follow the channel to participate and subscribe to this blog to read about official DAO updates.

Collect this post as an NFT.

mxjxn musings

Subscribe to mxjxn musings to receive new posts directly to your inbox.

Over 200 subscribers

Max JacksonFarcaster
Max Jackson
Commented 9 months ago

To be seen on main feed currently you must be curated by one of 30+ channel curators. You can also mint a DAO OE which (for now) is a direct ticket to the main feed. Minting supports the channel DAO and has more perks to be revealed soon! https://zora.co/collect/base:0xce4f649d4ef8fee2e6628184892a54d226308b89/2

CARDELUCCI🎩Farcaster
CARDELUCCI🎩
Commented 9 months ago

Love these colors!

WG 🎩🔵Farcaster
WG 🎩🔵
Commented 9 months ago

Thank you!

scizors|theythem|cult leader🎩Farcaster
scizors|theythem|cult leader🎩
Commented 9 months ago

just minted lfg DAO

aqueousFarcaster
aqueous
Commented 9 months ago

How do you know if you have been curated?

Max JacksonFarcaster
Max Jackson
Commented 9 months ago

@automod has liked your cast

WG 🎩🔵Farcaster
WG 🎩🔵
Commented 9 months ago

You get sent a up close datamoshed picture of my face via DC.

aqueousFarcaster
aqueous
Commented 9 months ago

So I understood about 30% of that 😂

WG 🎩🔵Farcaster
WG 🎩🔵
Commented 9 months ago

You get sent a glitched out close up picture of my face in a direct message lol.

KUSH🍄🎩Farcaster
KUSH🍄🎩
Commented 9 months ago

iHodl

Trips Farcaster
Trips
Commented 9 months ago

Amazing colors, remind me a lot to some fractals shape.🔥 🔥

WG 🎩🔵Farcaster
WG 🎩🔵
Commented 9 months ago

Thanks! My abstract work is mostly fractals :)

Trips Farcaster
Trips
Commented 9 months ago

You're welcome, great output btw! ✨ 🔥

WG 🎩🔵Farcaster
WG 🎩🔵
Commented 9 months ago

Oh this isn't AI, I manually created it with 3D fractals.

QueFarcaster
Que
Commented 9 months ago

20 $DEGEN

BIG COMIC ARTFarcaster
BIG COMIC ART
Commented 9 months ago

We created the term cryptoart and now i have to be curated into it?

Max JacksonFarcaster
Max Jackson
Commented 9 months ago

It's an experiment in crowd curated timeline over the default algorithm. There are 40 curators from the community. Purely likes-based algo seems to be favoring the same ppl all the time. I'm not sure what weve got now is better, but it was worth a try... https://paragraph.xyz/@mxjxn/curation-in-cryptoart

BIG COMIC ARTFarcaster
BIG COMIC ART
Commented 9 months ago

Well since we created cryptoart we've been pushed to the background the entire time in favor of celebrities, influencers, and scammers. Seems like a trend in every social media.

Max JacksonFarcaster
Max Jackson
Commented 9 months ago

I don't think that's what we're doing here. The main tab was already curated by the default algorithm. We're just taking control of it. Wouldn't you rather have an artist curated main feed than the likes-based one?

Max JacksonFarcaster
Max Jackson
Commented 9 months ago
BIG COMIC ARTFarcaster
BIG COMIC ART
Commented 9 months ago

Dope. I already minted this. I think I was the first minter but didn't know what it was I was just collecting cool stuff. 😎

Max JacksonFarcaster
Max Jackson
Commented 9 months ago

I'm not convinced about the token gated main feed although it has kept a lot of low effort/ bot content off the man feed. I'm open to exploring different approaches. Read the article let me know what you think and if you have any better ideas

BIG COMIC ARTFarcaster
BIG COMIC ART
Commented 9 months ago

🫡 reading 📚

Max JacksonFarcaster
Max Jackson
Commented 9 months ago

On the evolving changes to curation in /cryptoart https://paragraph.xyz/@mxjxn/curation-in-cryptoart

m/bransonFarcaster
m/branson
Commented 9 months ago

bookmarked! i have a lot to catch up on. thanks for pushing this forward. 1000 $DEGEN

🎀 sonya (in theory) 🐰Farcaster
🎀 sonya (in theory) 🐰
Commented 9 months ago

how about setting up a scholarship fund for people who can't afford the OE mint for whatever reason? downside: might be logistically cumbersome

Max JacksonFarcaster
Max Jackson
Commented 9 months ago

Definitely, I'd love to do that. I actually minted a bunch of extras for this reason.

ParagraphFarcaster
Paragraph
Commented 9 months ago

Check out @mxjxn.eth's latest blog post on transforming the /cryptoart channel. They're moving towards an artist-curated main feed to tackle censorship and gatekeeping. By minting or curating, artists can now feature prominently. Community feedback is essential for shaping this evolving strategy.

A Curated Cryptoart Channel