Cover photo

Curating Chaotic Channels

Leveraging Mod Bots for Collective Curation of Channel Casts

iSpeakNerd

iSpeakNerd

Welcome to the 24 people who've joined since last newsletter!

Thank you to those of you that collect my writings, it helps me out and keeps me going!

Grateful to all 246 of you for reading, hope you're having a great weekend!

Enjoyy the content, take it higher, and join the /nerdery channel on Farcaster.


Key Takeaways

  1. New Moderator account designation for each channel gives a single account responsibility to Curate the Main channel feed.

  2. Owners can use mod bots like Automod and Airstack to distribute curation authorization to multiple accounts.

  3. Channel Owners are figuring out how they want to Curate their main feed. /purple, /memes, and /gaming are all taking different approaches.

Farcaster Channel Decentralization Changes

Changes described here are live as of 5/23/24.

  • Only 2 accounts matter for each channel

    1. Owner - account that owns the channel

    2. Moderator - could be owner, another caster, or a mod bot tool

  • 2 feeds in Warpcast, a curated "Main" and unfiltered "Recent"

    • Casts get curated from "Recent" to "Main" by being liked by the Moderator account

    • Recent feed is made of ALL casts in that channel (even the stupid, off-topic ones)

  • Terms that have specific meaning

    • Curate means highlight from Recent content stream into Main feed of a channel, requires Moderator to like the cast

    • Hide means remove content from Main feed

2 options for Main feed, moderated or unmoderated. See below image for details.

post image

Unmoderated Priority mode works well as a default for Owners that aren't sure what they want to highlight yet.

Owners can have manual curation by setting themselves as Moderator, delegate to another caster, or distribute responsibility to a mod bot and grant their team authorization for access to the bot.

Updates After Publication

Additional changes in the first week since changes went live:

  • with moderation on, Recent feed is now shown in Priority mode

  • Unfiltered feed available to channel owners

    • This feed is full of spam in my experience, but good to scroll through to curate good content into Main

  • Owners can turn off Recent feed if desired

  • Choose between chronological or algorithmic Main feed

Mod Tools for Channel Hosts

Automod

Curate however you like by installing automod Cast Actions, can Hide content by removing from Main or Curate to move content into Main feed.

Airstack

Channel Experiments with Moderation Rules

  • current focus for the channel is retropgf round of funding for last 2 months of farcaster growth experiments

  • owner wants to keep content focus on retropgf

@ccarella.eth requiring members + text "#retropgf" for top-level casts

post image

@nonlinear.eth leading the charge with moving channel revenue on chain and redistributing the majority to the channel members via tipping

A labor-intensive process that makes sense for channels that require a high level of manual curation, leveraging Automod's "Curate" cast action. But it's better than previous monetization with channel passes.

  1. Better for channel owners - warps cannot be cashed out of warpcast

  2. Better for mods - revenue for their work curating

  3. Better for users - redistributing channel revenue to those that make the channel valuable

I've previously written about Cast Actions

[Cast Actions] give users not only customized experiences, but also users can initiate those experiences on any cast. They are not limited to casts with that particular frame in them.

So channel mods can use the "Curate" action on any cast to move it from "Recent" to "Main" for channels. This decentralizes channel moderation from Warpcast to other tools such as Automod and Airstack and allows channel owners to distribute mod abilities.

@cameron, @riotgoools and me want to keep it simple and hard to game, and bring the focus back to curated relationships

Following automod rule set Curates casts into Main from casters who are followed by channel hosts/mods or have power badge.

This is confusing to read but is basically creating an OR logic gate using multiple NAND gates (thanks electrical engineering!)

This is subtly different from the unmoderated Priority Mode, the Owner's follows get curated versus Priority which shows casts from a viewer's follows. So it's a more focused and content curated by the channel owner's preferences rather than the viewer's.
Owner can also expand the trusted social graph by adding additional "User Is Not Followed By" rules within the ruleset.

post image

If you enjoyed this,

  1. Please subscribe 💜

  1. Give me a shout on Farcaster

  2. Come join all the Nerds in my channel

  3. Share this post with someone who will enjoy it!



iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 5 months ago

hey anyone need a video creator, dev community person, and a docs writoooooor hmu @cameron @dawufi @cassie @samuellhuber.eth @thatguyintech @linda https://ispeaknerd.github.io/

dawufiFarcaster
dawufi
Commented 5 months ago

u mean u?

iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 5 months ago

Yessir

dawufiFarcaster
dawufi
Commented 5 months ago

wuf

Samuel ツFarcaster
Samuel ツ
Commented 5 months ago

okay I am in live. https://ispeaknerd.github.io/posts/work-sample-2-developer-documentation/ adding a little bit more context explainers to this and a image of the results in between and it's gold Video as cherry on top. That's kind of also what I try to achieve in our docs. Do you want to write about Farcaster by chance :D

iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 5 months ago

would love to, have done a fair bit of fc writing nontechnically, love to transfer that over to tech side https://paragraph.xyz/@ispeaknerd.eth/curating-chaotic-channels https://paragraph.xyz/@ispeaknerd.eth/passport-control-for-onchain-and-social-identities

↑ j4ck 🥶 icebreaker.xyz ↑Farcaster
↑ j4ck 🥶 icebreaker.xyz ↑
Commented 1 year ago

i am still not exactly sure what i need to do to now to set up channel co-hosts 🫣 the move to decentralized channels kinda flew by me and i need to spend a little time understanding how to now set up automod and also consider adding a hypersub. the learning never stops around here i also always forget the link to the farcaster notion lol so maybe the ask is add the channel notion link under the little i in channel details another client could definitely make co-host management a native feature via automod integration

jtgiFarcaster
jtgi
Commented 1 year ago

eyo – here's a walkthrough. tl;dr login to automod, add the channel, go to moderators & add folks, you mod w/ cast actions (for now!) https://warpcast.com/jtgi/0x8f9e97ad

↑ j4ck 🥶 icebreaker.xyz ↑Farcaster
↑ j4ck 🥶 icebreaker.xyz ↑
Commented 1 year ago

thank youuuu this is what i needed

iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago
isabel.eth Farcaster
isabel.eth
Commented 1 year ago

I went down this hole yesterday 😓 the new was seems to be to set up moderators on Automod. They won’t be cohosts exactly but will do the job.

↑ j4ck 🥶 icebreaker.xyz ↑Farcaster
↑ j4ck 🥶 icebreaker.xyz ↑
Commented 1 year ago

i see, thank u!

huugoFarcaster
huugo
Commented 1 year ago
↑ j4ck 🥶 icebreaker.xyz ↑Farcaster
↑ j4ck 🥶 icebreaker.xyz ↑
Commented 1 year ago

thank you!

L3MBDAFarcaster
L3MBDA
Commented 1 year ago

seems we need not forget the notion link!

Karo KFarcaster
Karo K
Commented 1 year ago

Q: Do you moderate your channels? If so, what do you use and how do you decide what to keep? Yes, I moderate channels manually. Currently, I don't use automod for any of the channels I moderate because I don't believe it effectively filters relevant content. Instead, I manually review all posts and give a "heart" to what aligns most with the channel's ethos and mission, ensuring it appears in the main feed. When changes around channel ownership and the introduction of automod were implemented, I found the communication confusing. My feed was flooded with opinions about the changes, but I couldn't find a definitive source of truth. Even now, I feel I lack a complete understanding of all the available tooling options. I see this as a fundamental issue that Farcaster needs to address if the platform is to reach a broader audience. Curating content should be straightforward for moderators, and they should be promptly informed about system-wide changes affecting channel operations. ⬇️

Karo KFarcaster
Karo K
Commented 1 year ago

To improve this, channel moderators and owners should receive direct notifications or messages about updates, including links to relevant information and guidance on how these changes impact their work. Additionally, there should be a comprehensive list of FAQs for each channel, detailing its purpose, allowed content, relevance criteria, and mission. This information could then be fed to a trained /llm that reads posts in the channel to act as an effective auto moderating tool. ⬇️

Karo KFarcaster
Karo K
Commented 1 year ago

Please understand that my opinions come from a Web2 perspective and are based on my experiences as a user. I believe these gaps are why newcomers without crypto experience may find it challenging to stick with the platform. Currently, the most significant incentives and value propositions are related to crypto networking and meme coins like DEGEN, or any future coins Farcaster might introduce. It’s not just the focus on crypto; the platform can feel burdensome to use and less rewarding unless you’re already connected with the community IRL.

Flash_BFarcaster
Flash_B
Commented 1 year ago

🔒💥 Secure. Trade. Connect. Join Cyber Vault on Telegram now and take your crypto game to the next level! 🚀📈 https://t.me/Cybercryptoguardbot #1644

iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago

recommend mine and @clauswilke's articles on the subject https://paragraph.xyz/@ispeaknerd.eth/curating-chaotic-channels most recent 3 articles from claus https://paragraph.xyz/@clauswilke

JCFarcaster
JC
Commented 1 year ago

I currently moderate manually /lightchasers The volume is low enough to do this. I look at every post. I wish there was a ban user option for the spammy/off topic stuff.

𝓜𝓪𝓴𝓼𝔂𝓶 ⟠Farcaster
𝓜𝓪𝓴𝓼𝔂𝓶 ⟠
Commented 1 year ago

I totally agree, it needs to be solved 🔥

sparkzFarcaster
sparkz
Commented 1 year ago

Shouldn't posts from the owner or host of a channel automatically show up in the main feed? Right now I have to like my own posts to get them to show up in main - or is this just user error? cc: @horsefacts.eth @dwr.eth

iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago

If you set yourself as moderator then yes you have to like your own casts bc only casts liked by moderator will display in Main. Use a mod bot as Moderator if you want it to be more automated, I'm using @automod from @jtgi Article I wrote https://paragraph.xyz/@ispeaknerd.eth/curating-chaotic-channels

sparkzFarcaster
sparkz
Commented 1 year ago

Terrific read, thx! 300 $DEGEN I’m gonna give no mod a shot then look into a bot if that’s not working out. Appreciate the pointers :)

iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago

Thank you, glad it was helpful for you!

iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago

Subscribe to support the channel growth and help tabletop gamooooors to make more moments ✨ together! https://hypersub.withfabric.xyz/collection/tabletop-gamooooors-txvflunq4sn4 Read the benefits in the linked article and in 🧵👇 https://paragraph.xyz/@ispeaknerd.eth/tabletop-subscription-launch

iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago

Access to and help shape the development of /tabletop tooling for playing and tracking board games Priority access to gaming events hosted by /tabletop

iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago

Discounted access to paid game tournaments like the recent Dominion-ation tournament https://warpcast.com/ispeaknerd.eth/0xd4d52eba

iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago

Access to the world's largest crypto-native network of tabletop gamooooors

iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago

Automated curation of your casts in /tabletop Subscriber casts get curated into Main feed by Automod Read about how that works in my article 👇 https://paragraph.xyz/@ispeaknerd.eth/curating-chaotic-channels

iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago

Year+ subs get a free Holofoil 𝙼𝙴𝙴𝙿𝙻𝙴 NFT, a /tabletop collaboration with technologartist @bias https://zora.co/collect/base:0x3c655fe65dbe96380c87f3764161fbbc125a98c5/1?referrer=0x3eEFAa9d6e2ab7972C1001D41C82BB4881389257

iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago

click gif to see hi-res

iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago

thank you @kenny! been awesome growing as gamooooors with you, here's to the next year! sent you a 𝙼𝙴𝙴𝙿𝙻𝙴 https://basescan.org/tx/0xb4515d5f013ce336daa1b89f49a5cc51134f7b190e2324b45645def5de06267e https://warpcast.com/kenny/0x22203adf

iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago

Subscriboooors only early access chat 👀 https://warpcast.com/~/group/j7NlRFG1T_VBT28JR__ELg

iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago

thanks for your support @mcbain! https://warpcast.com/hyperbot/0xb426ea58

iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago

thanks again for your support 😂 @mcbain! https://warpcast.com/hyperbot/0xf4944176

alec.eth🤠Farcaster
alec.eth🤠
Commented 1 year ago

experimenting today what channel tools should i use for /alec? intention is to keep a microblog and facebook wall for “fans”. ideally introduce a subscription for viewing or write access eventually. @ted feel like you’re doing this with /ted curious if others have learnings to share too. cheers

juxtonFarcaster
juxton
Commented 1 year ago

I went with @automod for /mugclub (project I'm spinning up with some friends). This will allow me to promote mug club holders (1155s) to Main and Recent feeds while hiding general public in Unfiltered. Check out this writeup from @ispeaknerd.eth: https://paragraph.xyz/@ispeaknerd.eth/curating-chaotic-channels

alec.eth🤠Farcaster
alec.eth🤠
Commented 1 year ago

Tysm

BPetesFarcaster
BPetes
Commented 1 year ago

Looking to engage fans with localized tipping/reputation/engagement game, check out tipster.bot no-code solution for launching tips in your channel.

alec.eth🤠Farcaster
alec.eth🤠
Commented 1 year ago

Hey hey long time Cheers brother

BPetesFarcaster
BPetes
Commented 1 year ago

Likewise! Saw ya here doing your thing for a bit and nice to say hey in the replies.

juxtonFarcaster
juxton
Commented 1 year ago

A helpful writeup from @ispeaknerd.eth

iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago

thanks for sharing, what was helpful about it for you?

juxtonFarcaster
juxton
Commented 1 year ago

It was a good introduction to different moderation approaches, and helpful for highlighting different moderation tools. In my case, I went with @automod for /mugclub

XipleFarcaster
Xiple
Commented 1 year ago

Good night sir apologize for asking you for Basepaint support here. I am still trying to get the ENS as my showing name instead of the cb.id . Already added the base wallet to the ens record.

Cameron ArmstrongFarcaster
Cameron Armstrong
Commented 1 year ago

is there a good "default" channel setup for automod? trying to think of baseline rules for this new world where we have to have rules set up or live with the uggo 2-feed solution

iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago

would brainstorm on stream with you, im doing the same rn

chinmay.ethFarcaster
chinmay.eth
Commented 1 year ago

Just read your blog https://paragraph.xyz/@ispeaknerd.eth/curating-chaotic-channels Was this stream recorded? Love to listen to the full version.

iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago

Stream is coming soon, Tuesday June 4!

elleFarcaster
elle
Commented 1 year ago

i'm split between automod and airstack now as they seem to have opposite approaches. automod now is about keeping out what u don't want whereas airstack is about allowing what u do want (⌒_⌒;) the automod rules i had before covered both preferences with a middle ground to manually mod. now i'm having to rethink

Cameron ArmstrongFarcaster
Cameron Armstrong
Commented 1 year ago

haven’t dove into Airstack with that much but @jtgi will probably build anything you want directly haha - he was super responsive to my DM the other day and implemented the feature I asked for in like 20 minutes haha

elleFarcaster
elle
Commented 1 year ago

yeah i asked him about autoboost/like being taken out ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

V5MTFarcaster
V5MT
Commented 1 year ago

So, airstack is another bot for managing channels?

elleFarcaster
elle
Commented 1 year ago

yes if u connect and go to your page on airstack.xyz (search v5mt), u can make rules etc. in the channel owner tab. i decided to keep using automod since that's what i used before the channels change and i only had to make a couple small adjustments to my config to keep it working well for /vip :)

y0bFarcaster
y0b
Commented 1 year ago

Channel owners: this guide by @ispeaknerd.eth explains how to get moderation going with examples and clear explanations 💯 Even if your channel is not chaotic, but could use a tidy up, check it out! https://paragraph.xyz/@ispeaknerd.eth/curating-chaotic-channels?referrer=0x704cf202792341d79a9fd6dd97046aa7ef3f4319

Cake One 🎩🔵🎭🔴Farcaster
Cake One 🎩🔵🎭🔴
Commented 1 year ago

Thank you! 100 $degen

jtgiFarcaster
jtgi
Commented 1 year ago

Nice moderation guide full of examples from @ispeaknerd.eth. https://paragraph.xyz/@ispeaknerd.eth/curating-chaotic-channels

iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️Farcaster
iSpeakNerd 🧙‍♂️
Commented 1 year ago

thanks for amplifying, glad it's useful y'all

inner 🍖 🎭 🍄Farcaster
inner 🍖 🎭 🍄
Commented 1 year ago

thx!!😍

민지🎩Ⓜ️🎭✪Farcaster
민지🎩Ⓜ️🎭✪
Commented 1 year ago

Good sir it's a good detail for us @jtgi ☺️

Alena TskFarcaster
Alena Tsk
Commented 1 year ago

thanks for the useful post

Curating Chaotic Channels